Hamlet’s Daddy Issues (Liam and Judy)

To be, or not to be, that is the question:
Whether ’tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
Or to take Arms against a Sea of troubles,
And by opposing end them: to die, to sleep
No more; and by a sleep, to say we end
the heart-ache, and the thousand natural shocks
that Flesh is heir to? ‘Tis a consummation
devoutly to be wished. To die, to sleep,
To sleep, perchance to Dream; aye, there’s the rub,
for in that sleep of death, what dreams may come,
when we have shuffled off this mortal coil,
must give us pause. There’s the respect
that makes Calamity of so long life:
For who would bear the Whips and Scorns of time,
the Oppressor’s wrong, the proud man’s Contumely, [F: poor]
the pangs of despised Love, the Law’s delay, [F: disprized]
the insolence of Office, and the spurns
that patient merit of the unworthy takes,
when he himself might his Quietus make
with a bare Bodkin? Who would Fardels bear, [F: these Fardels]
to grunt and sweat under a weary life,
but that the dread of something after death,
the undiscovered country, from whose bourn
no traveller returns, puzzles the will,
and makes us rather bear those ills we have,
than fly to others that we know not of.
Thus conscience does make cowards of us all,
and thus the native hue of Resolution
Is sicklied o’er, with the pale cast of Thought,
And enterprises of great pitch and moment, [F: pith]
with this regard their Currents turn awry, [F: away]
And lose the name of Action. Soft you now,
The fair Ophelia? Nymph, in thy Orisons
Be all my sins remember’d. (3.1.56-91)

Hamlet. A character riddled with – somewhat – good intentions and a heart set on avenging his father’s death at the hands of his uncle, may have a thing or two to say about honor and certainty. Maybe not good things, but useful things nonetheless. Hamlet plays his revenge plot safely, so safe in fact, it seems at some points he has no intentions of carrying out his homicidal justice against Claudius at all. This is because he’s scared to. Hamlet doesn’t know if he should do his father’s bidding and avenge his death at the cost of irrevocable repercussions; his relationships, his family, and his chance to rule Denmark, or just let it ride and defy his dead father’s wishes. This indecisiveness causes Hamlet to destroy himself alongside other characters by the end of the play. We’ve chosen Hamlet because not only is he is a perfect example of how not to go about restoring honor and certainty in one’s life, but he’s also a good testament of the very non-fictional consequences of the fear and indecisiveness that derive from this struggle, thus crushing responsibility as a whole.


Creative Piece 1:

The murderer is worthless without their victim
A king is nameless without his kingdom
An emperor is powerless without his empire
And the rich man
What is a rich man without the vain of the indigent to look upon?
And yet they still all resign to complacency  
For when faced with their responsibility
The plain which their honour is borne
The murderer looks upon their victim
As the king looks to his kingdom  
The king does for his kingdom  
As the emperor for his imperium  
The emperor speaks to his imperium
As the rich man speaks to the indigent  
And the rich man would speak to the indigent
And consign the latter’s voice
To death
Or worse;
To life
For they all hear in it-
A murderer to its victim
A king to its kingdom  
An emperor to its dominion
The rich to the indigent-
A rectitude lost beneath obligation
Appraisal lost beneath obloquy
Favourable, but only after the fact
Though yet still
The murderer kills their victim
A king desecrates their kingdom
The emperor rules their empire
And the rich man scoffs to the indigent
For conscious makes cowards of them all

– Liam Grey

For conscious makes cowards of us all. My favourite line from Hamlet’s soliloquy, I had to include it in my creative piece. I think that the soliloquy can not only represent Hamlet’s character, but also a good summation of the entire play. It encapsulates fear, indecisiveness, honour, and certainty, and ties them all together in a brilliant, albeit grammatically uninviting monologue. The intentions behind this poem were to grasp the finer concepts that those themes entailed, particularly the theme of indecisiveness. I’ve tried to draw parallels between a figure in power, and a figure comparatively powerless, or in need of power. The murderer to its victim, the king to his kingdom, etc… All to provide analogies more or less to the conflict that Hamlet faces with his father’s spirit. The struggle not to restore honour and certainty, but more the struggle between honour and certainty, and how fear is the instigator between that struggle. Hamlet, during the play, holds the advantage over Claudius for many key parts of the play, yet this power doesn’t seem to equal control. Hamlet dogs the opportunities he has to kill Claudius, because he knows there will be crushing consequences. Every murderer (almost) are caught, every King is dethroned, every Empire is usurped, and every rich man loses his riches eventually. This fear of consequence causes inaction and indecisiveness, that can almost always be more deadly than the consequences of the action itself. The murderer will murder their victim, the king will rule their kingdom, the emperor, their empire, the rich man will allow the indigent to exist- and Hamlet will kill Claudius- not before killing himself and destroying the lives of three other people in the process. The struggle between fear- the fear of losing everything, the fear of his father’s ghost- and certainty- knowing that honor can be restored by taking vengeance against Claudius (or at least having been told)- keep poor Hamlet, as it probably would anywhere else, fostering his crushing indecisiveness. To this, conscious makes cowards of them all. They seek the honour and certainty, but are held back by the humanity of what they must do.

Creative Piece 2:

Imagine the following scene; you wake up one morning with a horrible headache, suddenly, the sound of your pounding head is in tune with the ferocious pounding to the beat of yesterday’s peculiar events. Now, imagine a black figure, the exact one in the picture above; that figure is the embodiment of your fear. The figure is constantly trailing after you – forever in your conscience –  too close for comfort but too far out of reach. You can imagine how terrifying this would be. This is the experience Hamlet had; waking up to a horrible nightmare – a shadow of doubt trailing after him with his every move – after encountering his late father’s ghost. Hamlet knew his duty that was assigned by his father, he knew what he had to do, but he had fear; fear of the unknown, and the consequences that would result in his actions – this lead to his indecisive decisions. I chose to use the format above because visuals can evoke deep set emotions. The shadow is sulking behind in a forbidding, dark, and unsettling environment; by contrasting the colours black and white, the picture becomes hazy and unfamiliar, forcing the audience to unwantingly place themselves in the situation. One can feel empathy for Hamlet for they were forced to envision themselves in the situation, by doing so, they can realize how terrifying it was to be in Hamlet’s shoes.


Given Hamlet’s worsening resolve from the beginning of the play to the very end, it isn’t hard to imagine someone like you or I buckling under the pressure Hamlet almost withstood. The struggle to restore honour and certainty may seem a respectable endeavor, however, the liability of completing that quest becomes questionable when the honour in question pertains to stories told by a ghost. Given the circumstance of the play,the fact of ghosts may not be the deciding factor in Hamlet’s indecisiveness, more likely it was the mere fact of what that ghost told him he had to do to regain honour and certainty. Again, the struggle between honour and certainty is the hardest struggle. As it has been stated before, restoring one won’t restore the other, thus it becomes a matter of which one is more valuable. This is the distinction Hamlet is unable to make. He makes mistakes when they matter, and good decisions when they don’t. His struggle highlights the worst parts of what honour and certainty breed. The lack of honour blinds certainty, and without certainty there is indecisiveness, and without decisiveness there is destruction. Shakespeare is, at the end of the day, more than just art or creativity, but an alternative study of the human condition. As of now, we’ve mostly only analyzed the artistic side of Hamlet’s folly, so going forward, we’re going to be looking at real-life instances of how the conflict between honour and certainty that Hamlet endured breeds deadly indecisiveness.

Dealing with these aspects is much more common in society than we think. Throughout my life, in an aspect like Hamlet, I fear decision making; I am uncertain about the choices I make now for they could change my future forever. Although my life isn’t nearly as dramatic and eventful as Hamlet’s, decision making that is placed upon me educational wise this year makes me extremely uncertain; I fear that if I make the wrong choice or get the bad grades, that’ll decrease my honour as a individual. Furthermore, contending loyalties – loyalties that clash together – plays a part in our society. It is important to uphold complete support for what one honours, this could be a religion and it’s rules, but there are instances when our society compels the individual to make unholy and scandalous decisions against their religion or faith, such as requirements to for a job. This can cause uncertainty in choosing a loyalty to pursue, resulting in the individual to fear the consequences. An instance of this was in *Washington, U.S.A in 2016. A woman wearing a hijab working at a dental clinic was told to take off her scarf by the owner, she was given an ultimatum – she could continue to wear the scarf and be fired or work without it. The woman chose to keep it on, this got her fired from her job. This example in recent history makes us as a nation wonder, if we have to face fear and uncertainty when dealing with conflicting honour, where did we go wrong?

We can all live vicariously through Hamlet’s struggle. The idea of “taking risks” namely is something that we can all relate to in some way or another. A lot of us have been told that we must take risks to succeed, and though that is true, it is easier said than done, and sometimes being on the perpetual cusp of a risk is more harmful than actually taking that risk. We see that Hamlet, through his struggle to restore honor to his father, makes many glaring mistakes, miscalculations, and misses a lot of the opportunities he has to kill Claudius, and supposedly restore honor to his name. Though he has been told by the ghost of his very father that he must do it, he still struggles. He hesitates to kill Claudius when he sees him, despite the fact that he is clearly willing to kill Claudius when he suspects him hiding behind the curtains. He ends up killing an innocent man, Polonius and inadvertently his daughter, Ophelia. He hesitates, he doubts, he questions, he reconsiders; he’s indecisive. And other people paid for it. Hamlet, in this light, can be seen as a cautionary tale of the dangers of indecisiveness. The best takeaway regarding life skills I believe isn’t to do with honor and certainty, but rather certainty of honor. You must be 100% sure that what you are doing to restore honor, or what you believe to be honor, is right to you, because if you don’t truly believe what you are doing is right you will doubt yourself, and from that doubt will grow fear, and from fear, you become indecisive- and you will do nothing but harm – for you and everyone around you.

In ending, fear is the very substance prohibiting an intellectual from accomplishing one’s heart’s desire; you, me, and even Hamlet have suffered from its consequences. Hamlet – scared to take action for his kingdom as a result of the indecisiveness to obey his uncle and fulfill his duties, or to revenge his father’s death – carves the perfect path towards his own death; showing the audience the faulty route to take. The underlying truth in his heroic story facilitates the underlying truth in many of our lives; the question we ask ourselves is not the damned, “To be or not to be?” Rather, it should be “How do we live presently while we’re here?” The first question is strung around two choices; life or death, fearing both life and death. A life is not a life until you have lived. The latter of the two questions show you how to live, to be present is not to be narrowed down to two choices, it’s to make multiple choices – no matter how uncertain one is. This is the glory to be alive.

Fear is the very substance prohibiting an intellectual from accomplishing one’s heart’s desire; however, to be alive and to overcome, allows a floodgate of rewards and opportunities. Oh, how glorious it is to be alive.
Image result for burst of colour art gif


Who Did What?

Liam: Opening paragraph. Creative Piece #1, Explanatory paragraph #1, Transition paragraph, & Insight paragraph.

Judy: Quotation, Creative Piece #2, Explanatory paragraph #2, Personal Connection paragraph, & Conclusion.


Sources/ Image Credits:

“Clara Lieu: Scars that Speak & Wading.” Pinterest, Pinterest, 6 Dec. 2012, www.pinterest.ca/pin/178173728979446778/.

Guimarães, Miguel. “Poom, Illustrations of Explosive Color Obscuring a Person’s Face.” Pinterest, Pinterest, 18 July 2013, www.pinterest.ca/pin/485614772290795609/?lp=true.

“Instagram post by TJ Kirk • Nov 13, 2017 at 4:37am UTC.” Instagram, Officialamazingatheist, 13 Nov. 2017, www.instagram.com/p/BbbBkqalNn7/?hl=en&taken-by=officialamazingatheist.

*Pti. “Muslim woman fired from work for wearing hijab in U.S.” The Hindu, The Hindu, 7 Aug. 2016, www.thehindu.com/news/international/Muslim-woman-fired-from-work-for-wearing-hijab-in-U.S./article14556876.ece.

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

8 thoughts on “Hamlet’s Daddy Issues (Liam and Judy)

  1. Dearest Judy and Liam,

    Ah, the title of this blog. And the picture too. I am just overcome with emotion. It is beautiful, just beautiful.

    In all seriousness, I do think it is beautiful because it had the ability to draw in readers (or maybe it was only me, but I am a huge fan of this piece).

    The thing I loved the most was undoubtedly the creative pieces. I’m not fully sure, but somehow the two works fit each of you so, so well. The style of the work and the explanation combined together to create a really interesting experience of who Hamlet truly is, beyond the “to be or not to be” stuff. I really learned a lot from your blog because of this, and I truly feel as though this knowledge has enhanced my understanding of Hamlet’s character. Liam, your poem is pure genius, and Judy, the meaning of the art really helped me, as a visual person, “put an image” to this blog.

    I also really admire how both of you maintained your individual voices while still managing to create flow and unity within the blog. I know how difficult that can be, but you two handled it incredibly.

    As for the suggestion: I am generally picky about the layout because I have the attention span of a goldfish and thus lose my spot whenever I read. This only really affected me in the last four paragraphs of the blog, just because it wasn’t as spaced out as the rest. Perhaps consider adding some spaces or breaking it up with some pictures? (Again, this is just me pulling at straws while trying to find problems with the blog, there really is nothing much else I can offer.)

    Thank you once again for the wonderful insight you have provided! I will be looking forward to reading both of your future blogs!

    Sincerely,
    Tarannum

    1. Dearest Tarannum,

      I have never been so worried at my own brain as of this moment; because it/I had HEARD you talking, almost as if we were in a casual conversation. I don’t know, maybe it might have been the repetition of certain words carried out with that, almost, languidly mischievous tone of voice you have, or the constant pauses indicated with periods, something about your voice seeped through and I was thoroughly freaked out at my brain for a bit. Sorry, didn’t mean to go on a tangent about the rather unneeded commentary about my mind. Anyways –

      Thank you so much for your comment on this blog! Every word I read brought a smile to my face (as cheesy as that is). Regarding the aspect of improvement, I am entirely at fault for that, I think I just felt as if there wasn’t many suitable photos to insert at those sections so I chose to leave the simple things instead of trying to fit a unfit photo. With that being said, I do think spaces would have helped.

      Thank you again for your comment, much appreciated.

      Smiles,
      Judy

  2. Judy and Liam,

    You captivated me with the meme, so good job on that. Anyway, your beginning argumentation I found rather interesting, as you explicitly say that he is one who should not be emulated in restoring honor and certainty. In this, I certainly agree. Your first creative piece, the poem, I very much enjoyed reading, as I believe you essentially encapsulated Hamlet’s thoughts in a way, you even including a line from his Soliloquy. Stylistically, you had many poetic elements added in, creating an excellent piece. Judy’s creative, though simpler in theory, has heavy implications into Hamlet’s life. What i enjoyed was how you built up to the revelation that the shadow was indeed the ghost of King Hamlet. Like some sort of dark legacy and curse that followed Hamlet around, the shadow was present in the day, but by night time, the ghost would appear. The ghost was a manifestation of uncertainty, as he was caught in purgatory, a place between Heaven and Hell. Thus Hamlet was doomed from the start to a curse of his own uncertainty.
    I would have liked to see your last few topics titled so I could differentiate easily. I liked the personal connection of this piece, as you took it from yourself and your own struggles, to a society’s struggles other than your own. This transitions nicely into the insight paragraph, where you essentially offer advice and connect to the human condition.
    To work on, like Tarannum suggested, would be to title the last few sections, just so it looks better. Also, watch your use of hyphens and some word choices that may not work the best in the way you both have used them.
    Great piece you too!
    -Lucas

    1. Lucas,

      AHAH – thank you although I can’t take credit for the meme, it was all Liam’s idea. Regarding your suggestion, I am entirely at fault for that, I really do think adding titles to the sections would’ve invoked more interest and made the piece easier to read.

      Thank you so much for the comment!

      Smiles,
      Judy

  3. Dearest friends,

    Just as everyone else, I can’t help but laugh when you introduce your blog in such a way! It instantly caught my attention, and I couldn’t pass the opportunity to learn more about Hamlet’s Daddy Issues!
    I adored your storytelling in this piece, as I feel that when you make use of contemporary examples in society, it conveys to us how relevant your topic still is centuries later. In particular, I was very intrigued when you connected the story of the girl with the hijab to your topic. Being from a family of the faith, it made me feel more connected to what you were talking about. Furthermore, I enjoyed it when you spoke of your own experiences with uncertainty and honour. Since I admire you two greatly, I felt a great happiness learning more about you and your blog. Some other notes! I enjoyed your creatives, specifically the image, as I felt it was very creative to have the reader participate in your blog.
    In term of improvement, there’s nothing much I would add to improve, as all my suggestions have already been said. Simply giving each section their respective titles will add some flow and clarity in your work. Although it wasn’t an issue for me, it’s just something to consider!
    I absolutely loved this blog! Please continue to write more in the future, as I look forward to what comes next!
    Much love,
    Tim

    1. Dear Liam and Judy,

      Here is yet another person who absolutely loved your title choice – I clicked on this post right away!

      One of the things I loved about this piece as soon as I started reading it was both of your voices. When I first read the introductory paragraph, I was (and still am) blown away by the voice that drew me in, leaving me hungry for more amazing analysis of Hamlet. Although I recognize that both of you wrote separate sections, I feel almost as if you both have similar writing styles, without losing your respective voices either. I commend you on your ability to keep me wanting more and more. I loved it!!
      Furthermore, I loved the creative pieces – the two were very different, but also kind of similar in that they each portrayed a side of Hamlet that I appreciated being brought to light. Also, I think that the famous line about consciousness from Hamlet’s soliloquy most definitely encapsulates the scope of the play and is the backbone of why Hamlet can not overcome his uncertainty in killing his uncle.

      One thing I would add to your already excellent piece is perhaps to add a more cohesive flow – but I also understand that each paragraph was written in a specific way, and I wouldn’t want to lose your voices for the sake of a little more flow. Perhaps Tim’s suggestion of titles would help!! 🙂

      I absolutely loved this analysis, and I cannot wait to see what both of you write in future blog posts.

      -Carmen 🙂

      1. Carmen,

        Ah! I’m really happy that so many people enjoyed the title. Thank you for mentioning our writing styles for I thought our writing styles are quite different, but to hear another voice on this opinion dismisses my previous doubts. Thanks for all of your feedback and kind words Carmen!

        Smiles,
        Judy

    2. Tim,

      Thank you for your constructive feedback! “I feel that when you make use of contemporary examples in society, it conveys to us how relevant your topic still is centuries later.” I loved this sentence as this is something that we had tried to incorporate into our piece. Thank you once again for taking the time to read and comment on the blog Tim!

      Smiles,
      Judy

Leave a Reply to carmenml Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *